Detecting Hidden Residues

Jessica Kask square-1

Jessica Kask | May 6th, 2020

Hidden Residues is a term that we use to refer to residues that are difficult to see under standard facility lighting and conditions, as well as those that cannot be visibly detected at all. It's important to be aware of the potential for creating these types of residues and to have a cleaning program that effectively addresses them in order to ensure that problems do not occur in the future. 

Residues that remain undetected can result in failures on swab and rinse water testing. In addition, any residue that is missed can become a food source for microbes. These problems become compounded when these products build-up over subsequent batches trapping pigments and contaminants from the new product batches. All of these scenarios can result in contamination, the need to re-clean, and the potential loss of production batches. 

Use of a proper detergent and cleaning process can ensure that these Hidden Residues are broken down and effectively removed from the equipment train. However, it is difficult to know if a cleaning product and application are successful if failures cannot be effectively seen. Dober has employed several strategies to detect hidden residues and ensure their removal. 

Example 1:  Faint Particulate and Hazes 

Soils that contain pigments, and other insoluble solids can leave behind faint particulate and hazes. Due to the large scale and complex design of production equipment, there can be areas that are very difficult to see, especially under standard fluorescent facility lighting. When faint residues are combined with these conditions, there is the possibility of overlooking visual failures. At Dober, we inspect our test surfaces under both standard fluorescent lighting as well as with a 50-watt Halogen light. This more intense light source can make hazes and faint particulate stand out, becoming much more visible 

The photos below show a stainless steel coupon that was soiled with a pigmented cosmetic foundation. An ineffective cleaning process was performed, leaving behind residues. The photo on the left represents inspection under typical fluorescent laboratory lighting.  The residue is visible, but very faint. The photo on the right shows the same coupon under at 50W halogen lamp. The hazy residue becomes much more pronounced under the high intensity light source.  

Clean cosmetic tanks

Dober has achieved successful cleaning of pigmented hazes using the following detergents: 

Chematic 422, Chematic 410, Chematic 630, Chematic 1, Chematic 640 

Example 2: Hydrophilic Gel Layers 

Viscosity modifiers, such as carbomers, celluloses and xanthan gum can swell creating a hydrophilic layer that is difficult for detergents to penetrate, making removal less effective. When hydrated, a thickened “gel layer” becomes visible. However, when these residues dry, the only evidence is a faint tan residue, or no residue at all. Because of this, when evaluating detergents on soils that contain these components, Dober looks for swelling during the final rise step, and also uses offset lighting to look for faint tan residues.    

The photos below show a coupon soiled with a haircare product that has been thickened using a carbomer. After cleaning, the hydrophilic gel layer is only visible when they surface is wet. Once dry, the residue can no longer be seen. After several repetitions of soiling and cleaning the same surface with an ineffective detergent, the residue builds-up and becomes visible.  

clean hydrophilic gel layer

Dober has achieved successful cleaning of hydrophilic gel layers using the following detergents: 

Chematic 640, Chematic 670, Chematic 630, Chematic 25 

Example 3: Invisible Films 

Certain Celluloses and polymers can leave behind thin, transparent films that are practically invisible to the naked eye. They do not swell like the hydrophilic gel layers and they often go overlooked until microbial or carryover failures occur. During work with these residues, the Dober lab has found that these films can become visible in the presence of steam condensation. While this may not be practical in a large-scale filed application, it has proven to be a valuable detection method when evaluating detergents for complete removal in a lab setting 

The photos below show a coupon soiled with a liquid oral suspension containing Sodium Carboxymethylcellulose. When cleaned with an ineffective detergent, the residue cannot be seen once the surface is dry. However, when placed in the presence of steam condensation, the film becomes visible.  

invisible films left behind

Dober has achieved successful cleaning of invisible films using the following detergents: 

Chematic 640, Chematic 670, Chematic 670LF, Chematic 9250 

Conclusion

In summary, it may be difficult to determine if your cleaning process is successful when dealing with hidden residues. Cleaning experts at Dober are aware of the potential for certain products to form residuals that are challenging to detect. This awareness combined with the detection techniques outlined above allows Dober to ensure that are recommending a detergent and cleaning process that completely and consistently removes any residuals. This results in increased cleaning efficiency and avoids problems from occurring after subsequent batch production.  

Contact Us Today